For my teaching project I held a table at the Sustainability Festival on March 29th with a fellow classmate. We had the table from 11:00 am to 3:00 pm and so it was a significant chunk of time to get an audience. We had created a pamphlet to pass out to the different people who came by stating who we were and what our class is about. We included a brief description of the main causes of homelessness in America and what we think the answers are to the problem. We also included the main questions we have been working to answer in our class thus far about counting the homelessness, what it is like to be homeless, etc. We also reached out to local organizations and the community service center at the university to get fliers and pamphlets of the resources in the community. We had items from Redlands Family Association, Angels Closet, Option House, San Bernardino Sexual Assault Services, and a couple more from organizations who came up to our table and left their fliers with us. The purpose of our teaching project was to attempt to educate some of the community about the causes of homelessness. We wanted to see what people thought the causes of homelessness were and then teach them what we have learned to better inform them. We accomplished our goal of teaching people about the causes. Of course some were more on board than others, but it was a very good experience. The answers people came up with as far as what causes homelessness were mainly on the same lines as the stereotypes of homelessness we read about. A lot of the audience was surprised we were students and confused why we were not asking for donations or from an organization. When we explained we just wanted to educate them, some were really excited about it and others just turned away and left the booth. There was definitely a mixture of people whether it be age, gender, or profession. I learned that I have to be more outgoing to get people to the table. This was definitely my biggest weakness because I thought people would see our table and come on their own if they were interested but we really had to bring them in or they wouldn’t stay. It was a learning experience for us and I think it went really well.
All posts by Taylor S.
Internship Report 2
My internship at a domestic violence shelter has been a great experience and I am very glad I got the opportunity to do it, but there are definitely some critiques of the organization I have found, along with the positive things going on. The organization is broken into three sectors: legal, shelter, and administration. During this semester, the administrative sector has been completely reconstructed, the shelter has flooded and needed to have most of the structure replaced, and the legal sector has lost employees. Needless to say, it has been hectic.
There was a dire need for an Executive Director of the organization because there was no one really in charge. There were two people leading the administration and a supervisor at the legal and shelter sectors, but there was not any staff at the top. This was the first change to be made. An Executive Director was brought in to fix some of the things going on in the organization. The main concern was getting the budget back on track. This has been accomplished very well and within a short couple months, she has gotten payroll on track and gotten more grants awarded to the organization. She also has put an evaluation process into play which will really help the staff better understand what is expected of them. I have a lot of faith that this position will really help in a variety of ways. Without a leader, there is just so much disorganization.
The legal sector does great work and I am very proud of their part of the organization. They help people who need to get restraining orders on their partner due to domestic violence. They help anyone who comes into their office and don’t discriminate. I had the least experience working with this sector other than helping with their data entry, but I think they are the most on track. They have a system and it works, and so I don’t see why they would mess with that system.
The shelter sector is where I have spent most of my time. This is also where I see the most problems. The shelter is run very poorly and there is a lot of disorganization. The staff doesn’t know what exactly is expected of them, and the supervisor of the staff is very disorganized herself. The more educated staff and interns are not used well, and are asked to do things such as cleaning and laundry instead of completing tasks they are very capable of. Instead older, uneducated staff is put in charge of the main responsibilities. Education is not the only factor into making a good employee, but it is very important as an advocate for victims of domestic violence. There is a lot of victim blaming and criticizing. I blame this on a lack of training and knowledge on these staff and supervisor’s part.
Overall, I do think the organization does do good work, but in my opinion the shelter sector has a lot of work to do. The number one thing to be done is more training and education for the supervisor because with lack of an educated authority the whole structure falls apart. After educating and training the supervisor, the other staff needs to be better trained. The legal and administrative sectors seem to be on their way, and I believe they will be on track very soon.
Minimum Wage Increase
This article is talking about the minimum wage increase being discussed. After what we have learned in class about the minimum wage, we know the minimum wage now is nowhere close to what is needed to live off of. Different states are considering different numbers but it seems to be going in the right direction.
People’s Beliefs about Homelessness
This weekend, another classmate and I went to the sustainability fair to teach the community about homelessness in the US and what some of the causes are that we have learned about. We also addressed some of the stereotypes people often assume about the homeless population. It was startling how many people believe exactly what we have learned is not true. When asking what people thought was the issue with homelessness, most of them responded with answers involving blaming the homeless. Whether it was that they don’t want to work or that they are drug addicts or alcoholics, most of the responses were directly related to the stereotypes we have learned about. All this really did was further prove that this problem is as big as we are reading it is. We attempted to educate the people that there are other ways to think about the homelessness problem and that it is out of these people’s control, but most said thank you and went on their way. Of course some of the participants were extremely interested in what we had to say and were on board with our argument, but it wasn’t enough. There has to be some way to educate the world and having them really listen.
Sheltering Industry
Reading Vincent Lyon-Callo’s book “Inequality, Poverty, and Neoliberal Governance,” the talk about staff definitely reminded me of the shelter I am interning at. It speaks about the staff being professionally trained to fix the people who come in, and that is exactly how it is at my shelter. There is a very particular training for a specific type of person, and it does not apply to all of the residents at the shelter at all. All of the residents, however, are grouped into this category that makes them all seem as though they came from the exact same situation. The shelter I am interning at is a domestic violence shelter, and so there are some similarities between the women, but there is not a cookie cutter story behind them all. Every resident comes with their own very different story, and it is up to the staff to decide how to deal with that situation. For the most part, the staff treat them all the same regardless of what has happened to them or what the resident has come from.
http://www.amazon.com/Inequality-Poverty-Neoliberal-Governance-Ethnographies/dp/1442600861
Women and Children
In the book our group has been reading, “Beside the Golden Door: Policy, Politics, and the Homeless,” by James D. Wright, Beth A. Rubin, and Joel A. Devine there is a section pertaining to who is in the homeless category. It talks about the new homeless population having a lot of women and children. Women and children are the largest growing population within the homeless community. I feel this is an important thing to look at because it shows that it isn’t one group of people going through this. With women and children growing in number son the streets, it causes more people to actually notice. The children on the street have a lot of risks that produce a lot of negative effects. The main effect that needs to be looked at is the health of these children and youth. Their development is being affected by their homeless state whether it be from the shelters or actually being on the streets. This is something that needs to be focused on because if their homeless status starts this young, it can cause a lot of problems for the rest of their lives.
http://www.amazon.com/Beside-Golden-Door-Politics-Institutions/dp/0202306143
“Lets Make a Deal”
In James Wright, Beth Rubin, and Joel Devine’s work, “Beside the Golden Door,” the author goes over the common thought that people chose to be homeless. This idea is usually a conservative theory of homelessness and the conservative party tends to use it as a reason why not to send more support to the homeless community. The author compares becoming homeless to the game Lets Make a Deal where people choose a certain door and get whatever is behind that door. This is relating to all life, that people don’t know what the consequences are going to be of their actions until after they make their decisions. This is important when thinking about how these people got into their situations because most of the time they make a simple decision and it leads to a road they did not see coming. When people are asked if they are happy with their lives and they say yes, it doesn’t mean they chose for their life to be that way. It just means that their life has ended up this way and they have learned to accept it.
http://www.amazon.com/Beside-Golden-Door-Politics-Institutions/dp/0202306143
Domestic Violence Shelter Report
For my internship I have been working at a non-profit domestic violence shelter. I have been able to work with the shelter staff and victims of domestic violence and feel I have gotten an accurate portrayal of how the shelter works and runs. The shelter requires a lot of structure and has very strict guidelines for the residents. The daily schedule consists of a 6:00 AM wake up followed by a morning chore and classes beginning at 9 AM. Classes are from 9-2:30 with a 30 minute lunch break in between classes. These classes are used to educate the residents on the history of domestic violence while also allowing them to elaborate on their own experiences. There are also classes on parenting or job-finding skills. The overall goal of the shelter is to repair the mental damage the abuse has caused and help them get back on their own so they can afford to provide themselves and their children a safe home. After class the residents have 2 and a half hours to be “productive.” This could include apartment searching, job searching, getting court paper work done or something they need to have done before leaving the shelter. The program is only 60 days and so the residents need to get back on their feet and ready to provide for themselves in this short amount of time. 2 months may seem like a long time, but when considering all of the things these women have to accomplish while also letting themselves heal, it is very difficult. The staff is very strict about enforcing the rules of the shelter and once someone has 3 infractions of the house rules, they are exited from the program. These rules provide structure and allow the women to become used to a routine. The problem I see with the strict nature of the shelter is that the residents have a hard time opening up to the staff out of fear of being exited. The staff all care greatly about the residents, but there is a shortage of staff and so there usually are not enough staff to allow a lot of advocacy for the clients. The residents are welcome to come into the office for advocacy at any time, but with the stress in the office it sometimes doesn’t seem to be very welcoming. There is usually a volunteer or intern at the shelter to provide advocacy to the clients when the staff is too overwhelmed with running the shelter and answering the hotline. The residents end up feeling much more comfortable talking to these people rather than the manager or lead advocates because they have time to sit and listen. Someone to listen is what these women need most of the time. Overall the shelter is run very effectively. There are of course some victims who end up leaving before the 60 days are over, but this is usually because they are unable or unwilling to comply with the strict guidelines.
Reasons for Homelessness
I have known there were multiple causes of homelessness, but I didn’t know how much of homelessness was caused by problems completely unrelated to the homeless person him or herself. When reading about the different causes of homelessness 20 years ago I felt as though a lot of them still related today, but there are so many new issues today. With some of the main populations of homeless people having either disabilities, chronic health problems, or fleeing domestic violence situations is alarming. These people aren’t drug addicts or lazy. These are people who are sick or unable to work, and people who are being forced to either stay in a home where they are abused or become homeless. I think society forgets about these people. They get overlooked, because it is easier to think they are all doing this to themselves than thinking about the fact that they just need help. If everyone knew just how many people are actually homeless because of drug addictions or alcohol addictions, they would be surprised to see how low the number actually is. In San Bernardino County, according to the point in time count of 2013, on 24% of the homeless people surveyed had substance abuse problems. This leaves another 76% of people who are homeless for other reasons. Education to people about this problem has to be the first step. People have to be aware of how many people are on the streets for reasons they cannot change.
Homeless Count
When reading about the different ways homeless people are counted, I have found that there is a lot of room for error. Starting with the street count, I believe there is no way to get an accurate count at any moment in time because there are so many people who would not be found. It is a good idea, because without a number count of people who aren’t in shelters there is a huge lack of information, but I still feel there would be forgotten people. One big area of forgotten people would be the homeless staying in their cars. The people staying in their cars would not get counted in the shelter and institutional count or the street count. As far as the surveys, random digit dials could be extremely ineffective. There is no way of being accurate unless every household was contacted, which would be nearly impossible. I do think the process of completing homeless surveys by homeless people would be very effective. Because homeless people feel more comfortable with other homeless people, it makes sense to have them interviewing each other. The real question is how would there be a way of making it more accurate? How is the ASR supposed to calculate all homeless people when there is no real way of talking to them all or surveying them all?
http://www.appliedsurveyresearch.org/homeless/